Przejdź do głównej zawartości

Do WE save migrants and refugees or do THEY save us?

Do WE save migrants and refugees or do THEY save us?

What do you think about when you hear the words “migrant” or “refugee”? Is it a beggar in the constant need for help? Rootless and helpless in the search of own well being. Or is it someone proud, breathing with liveliness and full of ambition? Just looking for a right aerodrome for the flight of their lifetime. Is it someone who has to fit in, accepted in your community if they meet set of particular conditions and hide certain parts of their own identity? Or someone embraced unconditionally? My thoughts and associations are versatile and complicated: my sister is the bright example of intellectual migration to the United States, while my father had lost his hometown indefinitely in the heart of war conflict between Russia and Ukraine back in 2014, and could be a refugee unless our family resided in the other hometown. I am myself on my third year of BA in Warsaw, Poland, and could be considered as an economic migrant. Out of 12 members of my family, 10 members are scattered throughout the whole globe. Are we migrants or refugees? - I have a hard time defining us, and prefer to think about it as simple power of human journey and destiny.
The HIA Fellows introduction to the topic of rights of Migration & Refugees has started in Fundacja Ocalenie. It stands for “salvation”, which to an extent explains the core dilemma behind any migration & refugee crisis, as well as simply each migration policy decision on the state level - “Do WE save migrants and refugees or do THEY save us?”.
The difference in the answers have shaped political response to the European migration crisis, which highlighted to an extent that policy of acceptance is an achievement in itself, while the quality system of societal integration is out of question at all.
Integration into society is a multifaceted process, which involves steps from all included parties - institutional and societal environment, as well as migrants & refugees themselves. Gagik Grigoryan from the Ocalenie Foundation has highlighted the crucial role of NGOs in this process in Poland. Their activity is focused on various kinds of assistance, educational and cultural support, as well as dominance of EU funding rather then governmental, absence of transparency in grant application process, few organizations focused on refugee rights and inefficiency of existing channels of support.
On this wave, Karima Kanjo touched us with the story of her forced refuge from Aleppo, Syria and the struggles of integration in Polish society. Trying to save her kids from the reality of lack of water, limited electricity availability of 5 hours per day and the sound of bombs, leaving wealth and sense of belonging, she has settled in Poland in 2013 with her family. One of the main struggles she has shared with us is the loss of Syrian culture of interconnectedness and interdependence, substituted by European individualism and personal responsibility, which complicated her journey as refugee with low level of Polish language proficiency. Her husband struggled with acceptance of new reality by refusing to leave his room for 3 years, tracking the news and trying to keep a grasp on the lost world of privilege, which led to his arrival back to Aleppo in 2015. She was worried about the future of her children, brought up on the fragile intersection in the new society - her son preserved interest to Middle Eastern culture and her daughter embraced European lifestyle.
“When I think about the future I have a headache, when I think about the past, I have a headache, so I prefer to live in the present” - this is her approach in dealing with reality, as it holds no opportunity of coming back home for her and 3⁄4 of Aleppo citizens, forced to flee elsewhere.
We all could associate with her lack of sense of belonging, as a person raised in Christian- Muslim family - where holidays of both traditions were equally celebrated and respected- received no congratulations on either of holidays in her new environment simply by not being included anywhere. “People just want to live in peace”, away from battlegrounds fought through them by all the same hands. We shouldn't forget the human faces and pain of stories of migrants and refugees and remember the simple-complicated truth, embodied in Tariq Ramadans’ words:

Sasha Anosova, 2019 HIA Warsaw Summer Fellow
Pieces written by 2019 HIA Warsaw summer fellows represent
their individual opinions.

Komentarze

Prześlij komentarz

Popularne posty z tego bloga

When Protest Counts: Poland's Struggle For reproductive Freedom

When Protest Counts: Poland's Struggle For reproductive Freedom The early 90s was a very promising period for changes in Central and Eastern Europe. The “virus of democratic revolution” spread through the countries in the form of the New Forum in the German Democratic Republic, the Civic Forum in Czechoslovakia and the Alliance of Free Democrats in Hungary. Even though a completely new post-communist civic society developed in Poland after Solidarity came to power, some human rights issues have remained unresolved, even today. A special concern should be raised around the status and protection of reproductive rights of women. A discriminatory law on abortion introduced in Poland in 1993 outlines only three circumstances under which women are able to access this procedure legally: when continuation of the pregnancy endangers the woman's life or health, when the fetus is irreparably damaged, or when the pregnancy is a result of a criminal act (rape/incest). In reality, 90%...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej

I miss you Jew!

I MISS YOU JEW! Even the most engaged advocate for reconciliation can never deny the past. There is the presumption that Polish-Jewish relations have to be difficult. But what is the point of having difficult relations with neighbors who have lived by our side for the more than 1000 years? It is the different perceptions of our narratives that continue to polarize Polish society. Thus, in order to further the discussion about Polish-Jewish relations, we must agree that both sides are allowed to have differing perspectives on a common narrative. Polin – the Museum of the History of Polish Jews is the place where narrative was transferred to the Jewish people. The museum represents a powerful retelling or rather reclaiming of the Jewish narrative by Jews themselves. The Jewish perspective is a valid one. The museum paints a holistic picture of Jewish history. It celebrates Jewish contributions to Polish history, showcases the historical development of the Jewish religion, and sho...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej

Is Winter Coming?

Is Winter Coming? In the book The end of history and the last man, Fukuyama argues that, following the ascendency of Western-style liberal democracy following the Cold War and the collapse of the Soviet Union, humanity was reaching "not just ... the passing of a particular period of post-war history, but the end of history. That is, the end point of mankind's ideological evolution and the universalization of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government". But is this really the end of the history? The 2016 election made clear that the United States of America is a nation deeply divided along racial, cultural, gender and class lines, prone to populism. In Poland we are observing slow deterioration of liberal democracy that was established in the 1990s. The constitution is not respected, threefold power is undermined, the media is attacked, reproductive rights of women are at risk, marginalized communities are oppressed and immigran...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej