Przejdź do głównej zawartości

This Rainbow Is Complicated


This Rainbow Is Complicated

“I set my bow in the clouds to serve as a sign of the covenant between me and the earth” said God to Noah, when the rainbow first appeared on the sky after the Deluge. If he had done that in today’s Poland, he would have probably been accused of “homopropaganda”, at least by some members of the Roman catholic hierarchy. Because of its similarities with the seven colours of LGBTI+ flag the rainbow has become a source of never-ending controversy, of which the burning of the rainbow installation at Zbawiciela Square and the scandal around Madonna of Częstochowa with the rainbow halo are just two examples. This symbolic war is also symptomatic for modern Polish society, where different values and points of view are constantly clashing with one another. In order to fully understand this complex problem the tenth day of our fellowship was devoted to the issues around the LGBTIAP community in Poland.
In the first session we met with Gosia Kot, a Board Member at Campaign Against Homophobia, who gave us a comprehensive introduction to this topic. At first we looked at the situation from a legal perspective and compared the LGBTIAP related regulations such as marriage equality, right to adopt and anti-discrimination law in all the represented countries. Soon it became very clear that Poland and Ukraine are the only countries that do not offer their queer citizens any form of legal protection and relationships’ recognition.
However, some of the fellows from more “progressive” countries such as USA and Germany also pointed out that marriage equality is not the end of the road and it’s often been instrumentalized by politicians to cover other problematic issues. Nevertheless lack of regulations remains one of the main problem of the Polish LGBTIAP community and has a huge influence on the daily life of its members. For example queer parents - our next topic - have to deal with thousands of obstacles that heteronormative couples would not even think about. How to become a parent, when you are not allowed to adopt or have in vitro procedure? How to deal with the situation when only one of the parents is recognized by the law? And last but not least how will various institutions, including hospitals, kindergarten and family of origin, react to an “untypical” family? Despite all that potential difficulties queer families are much more common than most people think: it is estimated that about 50 thousand children are raised by queer parents in today’s Poland. “We don’t need your permission” concluded Małgorzata, responding indirectly to all the bishops and politicians, who think that they can decide, what “family” actually means.
The second section was dedicated to the question of conflicting values, especially between religion and sexual orientation. According to Misza Czerniak, a member of Faith and Rainbow Foundation, which brings together Christian members of LGBTIAP community, those two identities are in fact not mutually exclusive. On the basis of his personal experience as a gay man from Russia, who tried to deny his sexuality and even got married, Misza explained the religious believes that once trapped him, eventually helped him to come to terms with his sexual orientation, when he understood that God do not want him to suffer. Accepting both of his identities, he now tries to change the Christianity from within. But it’s not always easy. “If you are in the middle, you’ll be kicked by both sides” said Misza, indicating that he gets a lot of criticism from both the religious and queer communities. The debate was especially heated after the famous campaign “Let us offer each other the sign of peace”, which was developed together with some of the more progressive Catholic media, but caused a huge backlash from the conservatives. Still he plans to continue this course and put himself on the front line until he will be pushed out of his Church or die.
Misza’s dedication to his cause made me realize that althou
gh the members of the LGBTIAP community may have different religious believes, values and points of view, there is one common goal that we all share: the creation of the society, where everybody is equal no matter of their religion, sexual orientation and any other factors. I hope that one day the rainbow will again become the symbol of the covenant, but this time not only between God and men, but also between people.

by Hanna Jaśkiewicz, 2019 HIA Warsaw Summer Fellow
Pieces written by 2019 HIA Warsaw summer fellows represent
their individual opinions.

Komentarze

Prześlij komentarz

Popularne posty z tego bloga

When Protest Counts: Poland's Struggle For reproductive Freedom

When Protest Counts: Poland's Struggle For reproductive Freedom The early 90s was a very promising period for changes in Central and Eastern Europe. The “virus of democratic revolution” spread through the countries in the form of the New Forum in the German Democratic Republic, the Civic Forum in Czechoslovakia and the Alliance of Free Democrats in Hungary. Even though a completely new post-communist civic society developed in Poland after Solidarity came to power, some human rights issues have remained unresolved, even today. A special concern should be raised around the status and protection of reproductive rights of women. A discriminatory law on abortion introduced in Poland in 1993 outlines only three circumstances under which women are able to access this procedure legally: when continuation of the pregnancy endangers the woman's life or health, when the fetus is irreparably damaged, or when the pregnancy is a result of a criminal act (rape/incest). In reality, 90%...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej

I miss you Jew!

I MISS YOU JEW! Even the most engaged advocate for reconciliation can never deny the past. There is the presumption that Polish-Jewish relations have to be difficult. But what is the point of having difficult relations with neighbors who have lived by our side for the more than 1000 years? It is the different perceptions of our narratives that continue to polarize Polish society. Thus, in order to further the discussion about Polish-Jewish relations, we must agree that both sides are allowed to have differing perspectives on a common narrative. Polin – the Museum of the History of Polish Jews is the place where narrative was transferred to the Jewish people. The museum represents a powerful retelling or rather reclaiming of the Jewish narrative by Jews themselves. The Jewish perspective is a valid one. The museum paints a holistic picture of Jewish history. It celebrates Jewish contributions to Polish history, showcases the historical development of the Jewish religion, and sho...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej

Is Winter Coming?

Is Winter Coming? In the book The end of history and the last man, Fukuyama argues that, following the ascendency of Western-style liberal democracy following the Cold War and the collapse of the Soviet Union, humanity was reaching "not just ... the passing of a particular period of post-war history, but the end of history. That is, the end point of mankind's ideological evolution and the universalization of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government". But is this really the end of the history? The 2016 election made clear that the United States of America is a nation deeply divided along racial, cultural, gender and class lines, prone to populism. In Poland we are observing slow deterioration of liberal democracy that was established in the 1990s. The constitution is not respected, threefold power is undermined, the media is attacked, reproductive rights of women are at risk, marginalized communities are oppressed and immigran...
Prześlij komentarz
Czytaj więcej